Film Review: Silent Night Bloody Night (1972)

“Wilford Butler returns home on Christmas Eve and his house had been turned into a mental institution for the criminally insane. But the day of his return, he is set on fire and dies. The townspeople believe his death was an accident, and the institution-house is later closed down. Wilford leaves the house to his grandson Jeffrey. A few years later, Jeffrey finally decides to sell his grandfather’s house, but the townspeople including the Mayor have mixed feelings on keeping people away from the house, especially when a serial killer escapes from another institution and finds refuge there. The killer makes frightening phone calls and kills anyone coming near the house. But what does the killer have in common with what happened to Wilford Butler years before?” (courtesy IMDB)

I have something extra special for you this week from Lloyd Kaufman, the producer of such cinematic classics as The Toxic Avenger (1984), Sergeant Kabukiman (1990), The Class Of Nuke ‘Em High (1986) and Tromeo And Juliet (1996). Before Halloween (1978), before Black Christmas (1974), there was Silent Night Bloody Night (1972), the very first of the seventies body-count slashers. Made in 1972 but, due to good sense, not released until two years later, Silent Night Bloody Night is directed by Ted Gershuny and stars Patrick O’Neal and my old friends Mary Woronov and John Carradine. Is it a worthy stocking stuffer, or is it nutty enough to be roasted on an open fire? Silent Night Bloody Night is actually a rather engaging body-count movie that’s ahead of its time. The similarities to Black Christmas are definitely there, from the mysterious phone calls, the Christmas setting, point-of-view shots and general stalk-and-slash mayhem.

Writer-director Ted Gershuny – who wrote six episodes of the television show Tales From The Darkside and two episodes of Monsters – dips his lid to classics like Psycho (1960) and The Old Dark House (1932), while looking forward to the splatter films of the late seventies and eighties, which makes Silent Night Bloody Night something of a turning point in the genre, and even establishes some of the rules quoted in the recent Scream (1996) films:

* Don’t have sex.
* Don’t try to hide.
* Don’t open the door.
* Don’t drink or do drugs.
* Don’t answer the phone.
* Don’t ever say “I’ll be right back”.
* Watch out for falling anvils.

Admittedly, the connection to Christmas is pretty thin. The guy who sets fire to himself at the beginning of the film returns home on Christmas Eve, and one character sings ‘Silent Night’. That’s it. No killer Santa or Santa killings, in fact there’s absolutely no Santa to be found in this film at all! Speaking of which, this film is not to be confused with the similarly-titled slasher film Silent Night Deadly Night (1983), which may have been deadlier, but this week’s film is far bloodier.

Many of the film’s cast members were from Andy Warhol’s ‘Factory’ including Ondine, Candy Darling, Kristen Steen, Tally Brown, Lewis Love, Jack Smith and Susan Rothenberg. Mary Woronov, who plays Diane, was also a member of Warhol’s entourage, starred in a few of his underground films, and was a go-go dancer in the Velvet Underground Exploding Plastic Inevitable shows. She then married director Ted Gershuny and appeared in three of his films: Kemek (1970), Sugar Cookies (1973), and this week’s epic, Silent Night Bloody Night, which only goes to show that sleeping your way to the top may not always work out.

Mary’s most famous appearances include the Roger Corman films Death Race 2000 (1975), Rock’n’Roll High School (1979) and its sequel Rock’n’Roll High School Forever (1991), but her real breakthrough role was in the cult film Eating Raoul (1982) opposite Paul Bartel, in which they chow down on Chakotay from Star Trek: Voyager. She’s since had roles in numerous films including Blood Theatre (1984), Night Of The Comet (1984), Chopping Mall (1986), Nomads (1986), Scenes From The Class Struggle In Beverly Hills (1989), Dick Tracy (1990), Where Sleeping Dogs Lie (1991), Looney Tunes Back In Action (2003) and, most recently, All About Evil (2010), with my old girlfriend Cassandra Petersen, aka Elvira Mistress Of The Bark. Mary also made guest appearances in television shows like Logan’s Run, Highlander, Babylon Five, Amazing Stories, St. Elsewhere, Charlie’s Angels, Murder She Wrote, Wings, Family Matters, Buck Rogers In The 25th Century, Parker Lewis Can’t Lose, and Mister Belvedere – I’ll have to slap her in the face for that last one next time I see her.

Patrick O’Neal, who plays John Carter – not the one from Mars – was mostly seen in guest roles on television, beginning in the fifties, and always reminded me of a poor man’s Peter Lawford. In the early sixties he received critical praise for his leading role on stage in the Tennessee Williams play The Night Of The Iguana, and the attention earned Patrick lots of film roles, but they were all rather boring. He was usually cast in action adventures like King Rat (1965) and Assignment To Kill (1968), or in gruesome yarns like Chamber Of Horrors (1966), which is probably his best known film, but not because of him. Chamber Of Horrors was notable for using what they called The Fear Flasher and The Horror Horn to alert viewers to nasty moments in the film. Although made for television, the film was released theatrically because it was considered too intense. These ridiculous and extremely annoying gimmicks were added simply to increase the running time of the film.

James Patterson won a Tony Award for his role in the Harold Pinter play The Birthday Party, although you wouldn’t be able to tell from his performance as Jeffrey tonight. It’s not entirely his fault though – unfortunately James passed away from cancer complicated by extreme embarrassment immediately after shooting Silent Night Bloody Night, so somebody else had to dub his dialogue. Some actors will do anything to get out of a contract.

But the one name that stands out above all others in the cast is that of the late great John Carradine. True, it’s only a small role and he doesn’t actually speak – that croaky voice was dubbed in later – but hey, it’s John Carradine! His gaunt look landed him roles in many horror films ranging from an extra in The Bride Of Frankenstein (1935) to Dracula in House Of Frankenstein (1944) to an elderly werewolf in The Howling Of Frankenstein (1981). Early in his career he had important roles in mainstream films, including Stagecoach Of Frankenstein (1939), The Grapes Of Frankenstein (1940) and The Ten Commandments Of Frankenstein (1956). These roles quickly dried up and this wonderful actor ended up in such dubious films as Sex Kittens Go To College With Frankenstein (1960) and Billy The Kid Versus Frankenstein (1966), neither of which won any Oscars. In later years he appeared in Peggy Sue Got Married To Frankenstein (1986) and supplied the voice of the Great Owl in The Secret Of Frankenstein (1982), before his final film, Bikini Drive-In Of Frankenstein (1995), released several years after his death. He would sometimes appear with one or another of his three talented sons: David, Keith and Robert had two-and-a-half successful careers between them, as has his grand-daughter Martha Plimpton, who also happens to be the cousin of award-winning animator Bill Plympton, even though he spells his name with a ‘Y’…

I was about to go off on another tangent, wasn’t I? Let’s get back to Silent Night Bloody Night before I give you my entire life story. Hmm? Well, I was born at a very young age and, as I got older, I got bigger! I know, amazing…

Anyway, we have a rather gruesome climax for an even more gruesome film – we even get a Doctor-Cam view of the broken glass being placed over his eye, right before it…well, suffice to say he won’t be wasting any more money on overblown 3-D films. I dare say you’ll think more than once that this is a poor quality print in urgent need of restoration. Well, it’s happened! I’ve heard excellent reports of a recent restoration that enhances the viewer’s enjoyment – presumably by painting each frame black. Alas, that print is not in the Public Domain, so I had to discuss this moth-eaten strip of celluloid instead. It’s one of the pitfalls involved in venturing into the Public Domain. Tune in to see what terrifying traps await us next week in…Horror News! Toodles!

Silent Night Bloody Night (1972)

This entry was posted in Film Reviews and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Also, if you like following updates on industry Horror News..
Make sure to subscribe to our RSS Feed!

About Nigel Honeybone

Wee Willie"Nigel Honeybone's debut was as Hamlet's dead father, portraying him as a tall posh skeleton. This triumph was followed in Richard III, as the remains of a young prince which he interpreted as a tall posh skeleton. He began attracting starring roles. Henry VIII was scaled down to suit Honeybone's very personalised view of this famous king. Honeybone suggested that perhaps he really was quite skeletal, quite tall, and quite posh. MacBeth, Shylock and Othello followed, all played as tall, skeletal and posh, respectively. Considering his reputation for playing tall English skeletons, many believed that the real Honeybone inside to be something very different, like a squat hunchback perhaps. Interestingly enough, Honeybone did once play a squat hunchback, but it was as a tall posh skeleton. But he was propelled into the film world when, in Psycho (1960), he wore women's clothing for the very first time. The seed of an idea was planted and, after working with director Ed Wood for five years, he realised the unlimited possibilities of tall posh skeletons who dressed in women's clothing. He went on to wear women's clothing in thirteen major motion pictures, including the Rocky Horror Picture Show (1975) and Star Wars (1977), heartbreaking as the remains of Aunt Beru. With the onslaught of special effects came the demise of real actors in these sorts of roles. After modeling for CGI skeletons in Total Recall (1990) and Toys (1992), the only possible step forward for a tall posh skeleton was television, imparting his knowledge and expertise of the arts. As well as writing for the world's best genre news website HORROR NEWS, Nigel Honeybone is currently signed to star in a new series for television presenting the finest examples of B-grade horror. THE SCHLOCKY HORROR PICTURE SHOW is seen on Friday nights at 10.30pm on TVS Television Sydney, and where ever good Youtube downloads are available." (Fantales candy wrapper circa 2007)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>